✕
Honesty ledger — assumptions & limits
• Present burden, not a repeal forecast:
• y0 (baseline mortality rate):
• All-ages population convention: National
25+-consistent correction factor ≈ — this is why the headline is
shown as a band (25+-adjusted, more defensible → as-specified, upper-bound-of-upper-bound).
• GEMM is an upper-bound CRF:
• Single-layer/ground-level SR:
• Non-US remainder:
• GEMM risk threshold (the hatched states):
• Climate TRACE input-layer caveats:
• Out-of-state metric:
• VSL is illustrative: VSL = (2023 USD, EPA-anchored
central value) — prefer thinking in a range around the central figure, never “cost of deaths” or
“lives worth.”
• Cell mapping:
• Source markers are grid cells, never named plants: the coral markers
show aggregated source grid cells sized by SO2+NOx tonnes.
Individual coal plants are not named by design on this page; the aggregation to grid cell and
state is the deliberate ceiling.
• No demographic or environmental-justice view — and why: there is
zero demographic data on this box, so nothing on this page speaks to who bears the burden
by race, income or vulnerability. Building that honestly would need (a) US Census/ACS
race-and-income tables, (b) EPA EJScreen indicators, (c) CDC/ATSDR Social Vulnerability Index,
and (d) a defensible spatial join from this variable-resolution receptor grid down to tract or
block-group level — an area- or population-weighted (dasymetric) transfer, not a naive overlay.
It would also need its own caveats: per-state y0 cannot resolve within-state mortality
differences, so a naive version would understate real disparity, and attributing a group-level
value to individuals is an ecological fallacy. Not attempted here rather than approximated.
• Repeal-delta temporal anchor
mismatch: